Adrian Potter

How Do You Recognise a Good Insurance Broker?

 

Clients meeting with insurance broker

At a recent networking event, while exchanging the usual introductions about what we each do, I was met with the comment: “I always thought insurance brokers were just posh salespeople.”

It caught me off guard. My immediate response was to explain that insurance brokers do far more than simply sell policies – they can help individuals and businesses understand and manage risk, protect what matters most, and provide guidance when things don’t go according to plan.

Later, back at my desk, I found myself reflecting on that conversation. Was this just one person’s perception, or does it reflect a wider misunderstanding of what insurance brokers actually do? It prompted me to think about the qualities that define a good broker and the value they can bring beyond simply arranging insurance cover.

What to Look For When Choosing an Insurance Broker For Your Business

Choosing an insurance broker is about more than finding someone who can arrange a policy. For a business, the relationship can continue through renewals, changes in circumstances and potentially difficult claims.

So how do you find an insurance broker that is right for your organisation?

You could start by looking at how well they understand your business, the markets they can access, how clearly they communicate and what support they offer beyond arranging insurance.

Do They Understand Your Business?

A broker should take time to understand what your business actually does.

That means looking beyond the name of your industry. Two businesses operating in the same sector can have very different premises, customers, contracts, employees, assets and risk profiles.

For example, a technology company developing software for financial institutions may have different insurance considerations from a small technology consultancy working with local businesses. They will be working with different customers, suppliers and may have different contract conditions in place, which the insurance needs to consider.

A useful conversation could therefore involve questions about your operations, rather than simply asking you to select policies from a list.

Look For Relevant Sector Knowledge

Experience in your sector can be useful because it means the broker is more likely to understand the types of risks and contractual requirements you may encounter.

Ask what sectors they work with and whether they have experience with businesses of a similar size and structure.

This does not mean a broker needs to have worked with an identical business. It is about understanding whether they can interpret your particular circumstances and translate them into relevant insurance requirements.

What Insurance Markets Can They Access?

Insurance market access is another important consideration.

Depending on the broker, they may have relationships with a range of insurers as well as specialist markets. This can be particularly relevant if your business has unusual risks or requires specialist insurance.

Ask which insurer markets they can access for your type of business and whether they have relationships with specialist providers where appropriate.

The answer should give you a clearer picture of how they approach the insurance market rather than simply presenting a single option.

Can They Explain Insurance Clearly?

Insurance can contain technical language, but you should not have to understand every industry term before you can make a decision. A good broker should be able to explain the important parts of an insurance arrangement in straightforward language, that includes discussing limits, exclusions, conditions and areas where the policy may not respond. If you are unsure about something, ask – the way a broker responds can tell you a great deal about how they communicate.

What Happens When You Need to Make a Claim?

You can learn a lot about a broker by asking what happens after a policy has been arranged.

Claims can be stressful for businesses, particularly when a significant loss interrupts normal operations. Depending on the service offered, a broker may help organise the information required, present the claim to the insurer and liaise with the relevant parties.

Ask how claims are handled, who your point of contact would be and whether claims support is included within the service.

The insurer remains responsible for assessing the claim and determining what is payable under the policy.

Will They Review Your Insurance as Your Business Changes?

Your business today may look very different from your business two years from now. You might open another premises, employ more people, acquire a company, enter a new market or take on larger contracts.

A broker should be able to explain how they will review your insurance arrangements when those changes occur. Ask how often they normally review a client’s programme and, importantly, what happens if you contact them between renewals because something changes.

Transparency Matters

Insurance involves financial decisions, so clear communication about remuneration and the scope of the service is important.

Ask how the broker is paid and what charges may apply. You should also receive clear information about the insurance being arranged, including relevant exclusions, conditions and limitations.

A straightforward conversation about these points can help you understand the relationship from the outset.

Some Questons to Ask an Insurance Broker

If you are comparing brokers, consider asking:

  • What sectors do you work with?
  • How familiar are you with businesses like mine?
  • What insurer markets can you access?
  • Can you access specialist markets where appropriate?
  • Who will be my day-to-day contact?
  • How will you support me if I need to make a claim?
  • How often will you review my insurance?
  • How are you remunerated?
  • What information will you need from me?
  • How will you communicate changes or important policy information?

The answers will help you understand what working with the broker is likely to look like.

How Do You Compare Insurance Brokers?

The cost is one consideration, but you may also want to assess the experience relevant to your business, the markets they can access, their approach to communication and the level of ongoing support they offer.

It can also be useful to consider whether you feel able to ask questions and receive clear answers. Insurance can involve complicated decisions, so having a broker who can translate the important details into practical language can be valuable.

Can You Switch Insurance Brokers?

Yes, businesses and individuals can change brokers. However, the timing and practical arrangements can depend on your existing agreement, policy dates and how the insurance has been arranged.

If you are considering a change, ask the prospective broker to explain how the transition would work and what information they would need.

It’s also worth considering whether any action is needed to help avoid a gap in your insurance arrangements while the change takes place.

Finding The Right Fit For Your Business

There is no single checklist that can identify the right broker for every organisation. Your priorities will depend on the complexity of your risks, your industry, the size of your business and the level of support you need.

The most useful starting point is a conversation about your business or personal circumstances, rather than a list of policies.

A broker should be able to explain how they would approach your requirements, what markets they can access and how they would support you as your circumstances develop. From there, you can decide whether the relationship feels right for you.

Your Questions, Answered

Look at relevant sector knowledge, market access, communication, claims support, remuneration arrangements and the level of ongoing service. It is also worth asking how the broker will review your insurance as your business changes.

Ask about their experience with your sector, insurer access, claims support, review process, day-to-day contacts and remuneration. You can also ask how they would approach your particular risks.

Yes, although the practical process can depend on your current arrangements and policy dates. A prospective broker can explain what would be involved in moving your insurance programme.

Yes, the Chartered Insurance Institute (CII) is the professional body for insurance profession and many brokers will undertake CII qualifications. In addition, FCA regulated firms are required to adhere to minimum standards of continuing professional development (CPD) for anyone selling, advising on or transacting insurance contracts, as part of their regulated status.

Summary

When choosing an insurance broker, consider sector knowledge, insurer access, communication, claims support, transparency and ongoing reviews to find a relationship that fits your business requirements.

Adrian Potter

Director Enterprise, Brown & Brown

Adrian Potter, Director Enterprise at Brown & Brown, has more than 25 years’ experience in the insurance and financial services sector. Throughout his career, he has held a number of senior leadership roles, specialising in commercial insurance, business development and team leadership, with a particular focus on supporting SMEs across the UK.